The hat entered Fiona’s enclosure after a visitor tossed it in the air, and it was caught by a ceiling fan that flung it through a small opening above the viewing windows. Zoo spokesperson Michelle Curley said the incident was accidental. Fiona swallowed the hat about 11 days before her death, and her condition worsened as her appetite decreased.

Veterinarians sedated Fiona twice to monitor her condition and attempted to move the hat through her digestive tract using an ultrasound and a long endoscope, but the object could not be located. The team also borrowed a vibration plate from a horse farm and encouraged Fiona to stand on it in the hope that the motion would help. Despite these efforts, the zoo said, “it was ultimately too much to overcome.”

Surgery was ruled out due to the complexity of Fiona’s digestive system and the logistical challenges of operating on a full-grown hippo. Jack Kottwitz, an assistant professor at Michigan State University’s College of Veterinary Medicine, explained that hippos have a multichambered stomach for digesting plants, making endoscopic removal difficult. The zoo’s director of animal health, Mike Wenninger, said that multiple incisions would have been needed during a long and risky procedure.

Fiona’s death prompted an outpouring of grief from the public, with visitors leaving flowers and messages at a hippo statue outside the zoo. Cincinnati Mayor Aftab Pureval called Fiona “a symbol of perseverance and joy in Cincinnati,” and the Cincinnati Bengals referred to her as “the queen of the Queen City.” Online, fans shared memories of visiting Fiona and expressed both sadness and frustration over the incident.

Fiona became a global sensation after her premature birth in 2017, when she weighed just 13 kilograms—less than half the typical birth weight for a hippo. Her story inspired books, merchandise, and even a beer and ice cream flavor. The zoo had planned to keep the Festival of Lights open late on the night of her death, a typically joyful event that now carries a somber tone.

Animal rights group PETA expressed concern over the incident, calling it a “tragic reminder” that visitors must behave carefully around animals. Debbie Metzler, the group’s managing director for captive wildlife, urged the zoo to review its protocols and prevent similar accidents. The zoo has not yet announced any changes to its enclosure design or visitor guidelines.

Fiona’s death comes a decade after the controversial killing of Harambe, the gorilla who was shot after a child entered his enclosure. The Cincinnati Zoo has since faced both praise and criticism for its handling of animal care and public safety. Fiona’s story was seen as a positive turning point for the zoo, and her death is being mourned as a loss for both the institution and the city.