Netflix’s Monster franchise continues its exploration of infamous true-crime cases with Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, a new eight-episode series set to debut on September 17, 2026. Created by Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan, the series studies the controversial 1892 murders of Lizzie Borden’s father and stepmother in Fall River, Massachusetts, and the enduring mystery of her possible involvement. The show, like previous entries in the franchise, explores themes of repression, gender roles, and societal constraints.

Cast and Production

Starring Ella Beatty in the title role, the series also features Vicky Krieps, Charlie Hunnam, Rebecca Hall, Billie Lourd, Jessica Barden, and Sarah Paulson in supporting roles. The production promises a dramatic, psychological take on the case, mixing historical events with creative interpretations. The show’s creators have previously tackled high-profile cases such as the Menendez murders and the story of Aileen Wuornos, with whom Paulson has previously played in the franchise.

Episode Structure and Themes

Each episode offers a glimpse into the emotional and psychological unraveling of the Borden household; the first episode, titled “Blutbad” (or “Bloodbath” in English), introduces Lizzie’s troubled relationship with her domineering stepmother. Subsequent episodes explore the growing bond between Lizzie and her new maid, Maggie, as well as the family’s deepening dysfunction; the final episode, “Carnival,” reflects on the long-term psychological toll of the murders and the legacy of Lizzie’s story in American culture.

Reception and Expectations

While the show has not yet been reviewed publicly, early reactions suggest a polarized response. Some praise the bold narrative choices and the series’ willingness to blur the line between fact and fiction, while others criticize it for its dramatic liberties, particularly in its portrayal of historical details. Critics note that the show’s use of anachronistic dialogue and musical scores—such as The Runaways,has sparked debate about the balance between creative license and historical accuracy.