The 2026 NHL draft featured 224 picks across seven rounds, with the San Jose Sharks receiving an A++ grade for their strategic selections — the Toronto Maple Leafs selected Gavin McKenna with the first overall pick, while other teams faced criticism for not maximizing their opportunities.

Standout Picks and Team Grades

The San Jose Sharks were praised for making one of the best first rounds in draft history; they addressed key organizational needs while securing elite talent. The team is expected to have two of the top five defensemen in the class in the future; In addition, the Sharks drafted 7-foot defenseman Alexander Karmanov, who would be the tallest player in NHL history if he reaches the league. They also added goaltender Brady Knowling in the fourth round.

His selection was seen as a critical move for the Leafs, who need an immediate offensive boost — According to scouting reports, McKenna has elite deception and the ability to manipulate defenders, but concerns remain about his defensive engagement and pace of play. The Toronto Maple Leafs selected Gavin McKenna, a standout forward from Penn State, and McKenna, who had 51 points in 35 games this season, is described as a chess-like player with elite playmaking abilities.

Missed Opportunities and Controversial Decisions

While some teams excelled, others were criticized for leaving value on the board. The Buffalo Sabres, who picked fourth overall, selected Daxon Rudolph, a defenseman with strong offensive traits. However, with the team’s strong blue line depth, it remains to be seen how quickly Rudolph will contribute. The Calgary Flames, who picked sixth, selected Carson Carels, a defenseman who recorded 73 points in 58 games last season. The Flames are looking to end a four-year playoff drought and are hoping Carels becomes a key part of their future.

The Boston Bruins, who did not have a first-round pick, selected goaltender Yuri Ivanov in the second round. Ivanov, 17, posted a.924 save percentage in 17 games last season and could develop into a starter. The Anaheim Ducks took a big swing in the second round, selecting Mathis Preston, a right winger with 46 points in 46 games last season. The Ducks are looking to build on a second-round playoff appearance and see Preston as a potential key piece.

International Interest and Young Talent

International prospects also drew attention. The draft included players from the Cayman Islands, Russia, and across Europe. The final pick in the first round went to Jaxon Cover, a Cayman Islands product, which generated excitement for hockey in the region. The San Jose Sharks also drafted Brady Knowling, a goaltender with high-end upside, in the fourth round. Knowling adds depth to the team’s young netminder group.

Several young prospects are expected to have a major impact in the coming years. The San Jose Sharks, with their high draft picks and strategic selections, are positioned to rebuild quickly. The Toronto Maple Leafs, by selecting a top-tier forward in McKenna, are looking to revitalize their offense and power play. Meanwhile, teams like the Buffalo Sabres and Calgary Flames hope their defensemen will help them return to the playoffs.

The 2026 NHL draft has set the stage for several teams to address their needs and build for the future. While some selections were praised, others were seen as missed opportunities. With prospects like McKenna, Carels, and Ivanov, the next few years will determine whether these picks live up to their potential.