The NHLPA is considering whether to pursue an investigation into Mike Babcock before the Edmonton Oilers finalize his hiring, according to multiple sources. Babcock resigned as head coach of the Columbus Blue Jackets in September 2023 after an NHLPA probe into allegations that he asked players to show him photos from their cellphones—a move some saw as an invasion of privacy.

Controversy Surrounding Babcock’s Resignation

According to The Columbus Dispatch. The investigation into Babcock’s conduct was initiated by the NHLPA and concluded in September 2023; Not all players shared the same view on the incident. Some, including Blue Jackets captain Boone Jenner and defenseman Zach Werenski, defended Babcock, claiming the requests were innocent attempts to bond with his team — Others, however, saw it as a breach of trust.

Following the investigation’s completion, the NHL shared the findings with the Blue Jackets, and team president John Davidson admitted, “We got it wrong” in hiring Babcock. The coach resigned before the start of the season, and the Blue Jackets assistant coach Pascal Vincent to the head coaching role; Davidson and then-general manager Jarmo Kekalainen were both later removed from their positions, with Davidson transitioning to a senior advisory role.

Babcock’s Coaching Legacy and the Oilers’ Consideration

Despite the controversy. Babcock remains a highly successful coach in NHL history; he won the Stanley Cup in 2008 with the Detroit Red Wings and is 12th in career wins by an NHL coach with 700 victories. He also coached Canada to Olympic gold in 2010 and 2014 and led a world championship-winning team in 2004, earning a spot in the IIHF Triple Gold Club.

The Oilers. Who are seeking a new head coach after Kris Knoblauch’s departure, have engaged in discussions with Babcock, though According to ESPN, the team’s core leadership group has been consulted regarding the hiring decision. Babcock has also met with Oilers owner Daryl Katz and players, including star forward Connor McDavid, who reportedly gave the hiring his blessing after private conversations.

However, the NHLPA has not formally requested a new investigation into Babcock as of Tuesday night. A league source said the association was monitoring the situation, especially as players have reached out about the status of any open investigations into his conduct.

Controversy and Risk for the Oilers

According to Al Bat, the Oilers are facing a high-stakes decision. The team wants a coach with championship experience and a winning pedigree, but Babcock’s history with the Blue Jackets has raised concerns about locker-room dynamics. The coach’s request for photos from players was seen as a privacy violation, and the incident led to his immediate resignation.

The situation has been compared to a “powder keg” by Spanish-language media, with the NHL stepping in to ensure the league does not overlook the controversy. The potential hiring has also drawn significant media attention, with pressure mounting from players, management, and the public.

According to SPORT1, the Oilers are looking to elevate their game after three consecutive playoff failures. The team has not won the Stanley Cup since 1985 and is seeking a new leader to guide them to victory. Babcock’s potential return to the NHL represents both a strategic opportunity and a reputational risk for the organization.